They Know the Solution

Woman asking for land rights in Andhra Pradesh, India

She was one of at least 40 landless women who demanded to meet with us that day.  They had heard that we would be visiting their village to talk with women in self-help groups (SHG) who had participated in the Indira Kranthi Patham Land Purchase Program, one of several programs that the Indian State of Andhra Pradesh was implementing.  She was determined that we hear her message. That day was one of the more difficult days of my career as a lawyer advocating for land rights for the world’s poorest.

The AP Land Purchase Program, which Landesa and RDI-India helped the State design, assisted landless women in organizing to negotiate with large landowners and purchase and subdivide agricultural land for themselves and their families.  From 2004 to 2009, 5,303 women paid US $604,418 (just over $100 each) to purchase 4,539 acres of farmland.  The women paid a total of 25% of the purchase price, 15% of which they borrowed.  The government subsidized the remaining amount.  For weeks, our team  had been traveling throughout the state, talking with formerly landless women whose lives had been transformed through the program.  Most of the women had owned the land for about four years, with titles to their land in their name alone.  State law permits only one name on the patta, or title, and the State required that the patta had to be in the name of the wife (if married) or a female head of household.

The women whom we interviewed reported significant benefits associated with shedding the “landless” cloak and becoming a full-fledged landowner.  They reported increased income and the ability to start saving, improvement in their family’s health due to having more food to consume and higher quality food, and the ability to access credit from banks and village moneylenders.  They also perceived an improvement in their family’s status within the community as evidenced by having better marriage opportunities for their children.  Although the women reported that there still was room for improvement on all fronts, for them, becoming a landowner had profound effects on their family’s welfare.

We also asked the women questions about the fact that the land was titled solely in their own names and not their husbands’ names (the vast majority of beneficiaries were married).  Benefits that the women reported included:  (1) she receives more respect from her husband, including less physical abuse; (2) land titled in her name prevents her husband from selling land without her knowledge; (3) land titled in her name reduces the likelihood that her husband will evict her; and (4) with land titled in her name, her husband, her children and her community respect her more.  The village leaders with whom we spoke echoed these responses and also noted that the women seemed more confident.

It was the second to the last day of our fieldwork and so much of what we had learned was positive.  We were hearing vast improvements in formerly landless peoples’ lives.  But this woman, and others, introduced us to the other side of the story.

Yes, with our assistance, IKP had helped thousands of women. In fact, in partnership with the national and several state governments, Landesa and RDI-India has helped 2.3 million families across India become land owners and climb out of extreme poverty. But this group of women represented the remaining 15 million families (60 million people in all) who remain landless.

They were the unlucky ones.

Because of the overwhelming demand, the program had very strict criteria. Some women could not participate because they were too old. Others literally drew a bad lot in the lottery IKP held to determine participation in the program.

Nevertheless, these women were determined. They offered to put up even more than the usual 25 percent. They offered to accept even less than the usual one acre. They were desperate for the opportunity to improve their own lives and the lives of their families. But there was just no path forward for them.

These women know what is keeping them poor and they know the solution. And so do we. The question is: how much longer will it take for us to be able to reach all of those in need of land?

40 women of the 15 million landless people in Andhra Pradesh, IndiaPhotos and text by Deborah Espinosa

Deborah Espinosa

About Deborah Espinosa

At the time this piece was written, Deborah Espinosa was a senior attorney, land tenure specialist, and photographer at Landesa. She is a land law and policy attorney with expertise in land tenure policy, legal and regulatory reform, women’s access and rights to land, land-related conflicts and dispute resolution, land titling and registration, and legal literacy. She also has broad expertise in environmental and natural resources law. Deborah has performed rural fieldwork to understand land-related customary law for purposes of designing new land policy, legislation, and interventions, with particular emphasis on women’s access to land. She has assessed a variety of proposed and existing land laws and policies, land conflict and dispute resolution mechanisms, and government-sponsored land programs. She has managed land dispute resolution and legal aid programs. Deborah is also an accomplished photographer. She is responsible for many of the powerful images on this website as well as many of the beautiful images in Landesa's print material. Her international experience includes Burundi, India, Kazakhstan, Kenya, Kyrgyz Republic, Russian Federation, and Rwanda. Deborah earned her J.D. from the University of Washington School of Law and an M.A. in Russian, East European & Central Asian Studies from the Jackson School of International Studies at the University of Washington. She also holds a Certificate in Career Training from the Rocky Mountain School of Photography and a B.A. in history from the University of California, Berkeley.
This entry was posted in Photography, Women's Land Rights and tagged , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

From Our Blog

Melany Grout

5 girls who said NO to child marriage in West Bengal

This photo essay originally appeared on ONE.org. The Girls Project, a partnership between the government of West Bengal and Landesa, aims to keep girls in school and reduce their vulnerability to child marriage. More than 40,000 girls are currently participating in …
Read More

Tim Hanstad

A New Chapter

During my 27 years at Landesa, including the last ten as CEO and President, I’ve had the privilege of seeing both Landesa and the issue of land rights grow in prominence. A quarter century ago, few people were talking about …
Read More

Roy Prosterman

10 Lessons Learned on the Impact of Secure Land Rights

Got land rights? If you live in North America or Europe, the answer is probably: yes. If you live in the developing world, the answer is more likely: no. Your answer to this simple question largely determines your ability to …
Read More

On Twitter